When Nobody Likes Your Movie
What if your favourite film is not a favourite of those who made it?
It’s not even a favourite, it’s probably even disregarded by all the actors in the film.
So much so that the film is considered a flop by its lead actor.
The writer of the movie does not want to talk about it.
It is very likely that the second lead misremembers the film.
Yes, Simla Special is my favourite movie and in many ways this is a pleasant tragedy.
All these thoughts came rushing into my head because of a video by actor-dramatist Sve Sekar on his youtube channel about Simla Special.
Writing about Sve Sekar’s youtube channel would be an episode by itself, it started off as a political commentary channel – when controversy followed the channel took a spiritual turn. It again became political for a while before Sve decided to run through his own filmography. It was the practical thing to do.
And then he spoke about Simla Special.
If you are here and have just read a whole paragraph about Sves50TV, then probably Simla Special is special for you too.
If not, these words won’t go anywhere- it is best you see the film first.
There are going to be spoilers and you’ve had 42 years to catch up.
To put it simply, Simla Special is about the fictional Gopu – Babu Amateur Drama Company duo who strike a deal with Simla Tamil Sangam to stage 6 Tamil dramas over a week in Simla for a sum of Rs 35,000.
Gopu and Babu are played by possibly the best comedy pair assembled at the time, Kamal Haasan and Sve Sekar
This 35,000, Gopu & Babu believe can be used to fund Babu’s sister’s wedding. But things take multiple dramatic turns (pun intended) when the troupe lands in Simla.
Amma va? Drama va?
Conflicts reach the pinnacle when Gopu’s mother becomes seriously ill in Chennai (then Madras) – a friend calls to get Gopu back to Chennai, but only reaches Babu, who under tremendous stress chooses to withhold this information from Gopu. He fears Gopu leaving Simla will only affect his sister’s wedding.
As fate would have it, the friend gets through to Gopu and how Gopu handles Babu’s betrayal forms the last part of this 1982 film.
1982 is a long time ago
It is only understandable that Sve Sekar misremembers Simla Special, he probably wouldn’t have watched it in a while.
A case of bad memory #1
In his video, Sve states that when news of Gopu’s mom reaches him he takes money from the drama deal and sends it to Chennai for Babu’s mother’s treatment!
Anyone who has seen the movie knows this is not the case. There was not even a hint that Gopu needed money for his mother’s treatment and it was only Babu who badly needed money.
The first half of the film sets Gopu and Babu’s relationship as one can best be described in proper Chennai (then Madras) terms as a Mylapore-Mambalam friendship.
Babu probably being from a slightly economically backward part and even though naturally funny, he runs the troupe in the hope of getting some extra income.
Mambalam people, really practical, who also do side hustle.
Gopu, of course is here for passion, art, humor, friendship- that kind of thing.
Clearly Mylapore.
And there is clearly not even a hint of this money transfer.
A case of bad memory #2
Sve goes on to say that the movie makers somehow wanted to make him the villain of the film towards the end, he also says that there were more scenes of Kamal bashing him during the climactic song Unakkenna Mele Nindrai which were then edited out when Sivaji Ganesan (in a consultative capacity) intervened and said Babu is really not the villain of the film.
Again, Babu was never the villain of the film- he doesn’t become one because of that one decision in Simla, his ‘selfishness’ is what drives the whole movie and it is established right from the start.
Simla Special is a film that does not need a villain and it was written by Visu who had excelled in writing movies in which the only villain available was the situation.
And Gopu does not thrash Babu during the climactic song, but in the drama scenes just before that.
Which is why I’m sure Sve has not seen the film in a long time.
I, on the other hand, jobless that I am, see Simla Special every other month.
There is no need for Sve Sekar or Babu to feel like a victim because Babu is really the better written character in the film and Sve brings out the thin line between being practical and being selfish brilliantly. It’s probably his best role.
Which is why I feel that Sve’s need to self-victimize in his Simla Special videos totally misplaced.
And Simla Special really does not need a villain.
It is one of those hang out films which can be watched from anywhere, at anytime. Atleast for me.
Simla Special um Naanum
If you search for Kalapovadhu Kamal on youtube, you will come across a video where Kamal introduces Simla Special as a movie which was so-so but the songs would always be remembered.
SPB (God bless him) then goes on to render one of the most soulful explorations of the song, the type when you don’t really need the lyrics to get the feeling of broken friendship.
The video makes me angsty even now, because Simla Special was not really a flop.
The movie ran for 99 days and the producers known to be extremely cautious on spending removed the movie from theatres just to save on not having a success meet.
Contrast that to now, when a movie running for just one week in the theatre is considered a grand success.
Nevertheless, I do not care much about box office, I just wanted to point out another instance of how people involved in the film really don’t care much about it to even remember if it was a hit.The team did not know they had gold in their hands.
And gold it was, everytime it was on TV and that’s how a movie elongates its lifespan. Now too, the movie enjoys a good following on youtube.
One such golden morning ( Simla Special almost always played in the early morning slots), I delayed going to chemistry tuition just so that I can see Unakena Mele Nindrai once more.
One. Two. Three. Four.
That’s how MSV-SPB-Valee start this song,which while having within itself all the qualities of just another Golden 80s hit number also chooses to bring all the threads together to end the film.
Almost wordless, absolutely brilliant choice for a movie that’s so far rests almost entirely on dialogues.
It’s also this decision which gives some credence to Sve’s theories about earlier drafts but they would have remained as drafts. Once they had this song and how Kamal elevates it with a solo dance that brings out the disappointment and the betrayal, no more words required.
A compact and weighty few minutes in a film full of laughs.
So I carried this weight to chemistry tuition, the guy next to me got talking on why I had been late. Naturally, we talked about Simla Special.
He being ‘musically’ inclined and of a certain generation who thought that every 80s hummable song was like : “wow unakenna mele nindrai, classic Raja le? Raja raja dan!”
I didn’t correct him then, but then I find favor with MSV.
Imagine MSV composing such a song and then being misattributed.
Similarly.
Imagine Kamal choreographing the song and then going on disregarding the film.
Imagine Sve getting one of the best roles in his career only to misremember it.
Imagine Mukta Srinivasan directing and producing a hit film only to pull it out one day before its 100 day run.
There’s something to say about Simla Special and the people who made it.
But this essay probably says more about me than the film, that micro minority who wishes to see one more episode of Gopu Babu’s adventures.
Maybe this time it’s not Simla. But a reunion surely can be special.